Tag: economy deteriorating

  • 3.2% GDP recorded in 2nd quarter does not mean the economy has recovered – Economist 

     

     

    Adnan Adams Mohammed

     

    A finance expert has shot-down arguments by government actors that the second quarter Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of 3.2 percent as recorded shows that the economy of Ghana is recovered from its deteriorated stage.

     

    The expert alluded that, conscientious examination of the macro-economic indicators and targets show that the country has not recovered.

     

    Reacting to some commentaries by government actors and economists, after the Ghana Statistical Service released the second quarter economic figures, who are of the view that, although the 3.2% is slower as compared to the first quarter growth of 3.3% as revised from 4.2 yet it is a sign that the economy is recovering. 

     

    “What we are seeing now is that government’s spending is driving this expansion, for the second quarter of this year and not real economic activities undertaking by businesses,” Professor Lord Mensah, Lecturer at University of Ghana Business School said in an interview last week.  

     

    “A lot more needs to be done. Government’s spending is driving this expansion, and not real economic activities undertaking by business”, he stressed.

     

    Prof. Mensah pointed out that real growth would have positively impacted on government’s revenue.

     

    Figures released by the Ghana Statistical Service highlighted a decline in the growth of the Ghanaian economy, particularly in the industrial sector, which continues to face challenges. During the second quarter of 2023, the economy expanded at a rate of 3.2%, a figure notably smaller than the previous year’s performance (3.5%).

     

    Several key subsectors, including construction, electricity, and manufacturing, all experienced contractions during this period, contributing to the overall economic slowdown. Statistical Service also revised the growth rate for the first quarter of 2023, adjusting it from the earlier reported 4.2% down to 3.3%.

     

    In the second quarter of 2023, the economy displayed a mix of expansion and contraction across various sectors. Notably, the Information & Communication sector experienced remarkable growth, expanding by 26.4%. Fishing also saw a substantial expansion of 12.2% and Social Work expanded by 11.0%.

     

    However, six sub-sectors faced contraction during this period, with construction showing the most significant decline at -11.7%, suggesting potential challenges in the construction industry. Trade, along with repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles, contracted by -5.3%.

     

    Electricity, forestry, water supply, sewerage, waste management and remediation activities, and manufacturing also experienced varying degrees of contraction.  

     

     

    Ghana’s government has already revised its economic projections for the year, reducing the growth forecast by approximately 50%. Additionally, the country is now expecting higher inflation and a primary deficit, a significant shift from the previous hope for a surplus.

     

    During the mid-year budget review in parliament, Finance Minister Ken Ofori-Atta disclosed that last year’s budget deficit was 11.8 per cent of GDP, nearly double the initial target of 6.3 per cent. For 2023, the government anticipates the economy to grow by 1.5 per cent, down from the earlier projection of 2.8 per cent.

     

    These adjustments are attributed to fiscal consolidation measures and challenging global economic conditions.

     

    This downward revision in projected growth for 2023 is attributed to a general slowdown in all three sectors of the economy, influenced by factors such as the fiscal consolidation plan under the three-year IMF-supported programme and challenging global conditions.

     

    Nevertheless, the Finance Minister remains hopeful, projecting that the overall GDP growth will rebound to 2.8%, 4.7% and 4.9% in 2024, 2025 and 2026, respectively.

     

  • Postmortem of Ghana’s economy and the DDE

    Adnan Adams Mohammed

     

    Ghanaians are facing a period of economic harshness never experienced after the periods of the military junta in 1980’s.

     

    While inflation is beating about three decades records to record over 54 percent for November 2022 year on year, the Ghana cedi losing value to by over 50 percent to be adjudged as the worst performing currency as at November last year and current ranking second worst performing currency according to Bloomberg data.

     

    Also the country defaulted in debt servicing to both domestic and foreign debtors as the country’s accumulated debt surpassed its Gross Domestic Product recording over over 105 percent debt to GDP ratio. All these compounded with already global slowdown in economic growth and business activities and as well as drop in remittance to the subharran regions.

     

    To anihililate  the current challenges, a finance expert has done a deep postmortem analysis of Ghana’s current economic woes and attributed the ‘big factor’ to reckless borrowing and expenditure.

     

    In a question and answer session with a former executive director with Standard Chartered Bank, Alex K. Mensah Mould, he outlined the causes and solutions to our current economic challenge leading us into a ‘killer’ debt restructuring arrangements under the Domestic Debt Exchange (DDE).

     

    1. Why are we asking for the DDE?

     

    Ans. The financial crisis was largely a result of structural problems that ignored the loss of tax revenue and the slow down in growth in key sectors in a sustainable way

     

    Government was simply not bringing in enough money to cover its growing expenditure including its debt service

     

    This has been exacerbated by high inflation, high physical deficits, low growth in key sectors ,and problems with the exchange rate

     

    1. How did we get here?

     

    Ans. Financial indiscipline and taking wrong bets via ill-thought through policies emanating from populist manifeato promises

     

    Govt also  were not constrained in its financial management and violated many covenants it signed up for; namely:

     

    – Deficit not more than 5% of GDP

    – Public debt to below 60% of GDP

     

    Govt also misrepresented its ability to keep the exchange rate under control by supporting the Cedi via sustainable strong exports and a strong trade surplus

     

    As long as borrowing cost remained relatively cheap and the economy was still growing then issues like current account deficit continued to be ignored

     

    What government did not do was to stress test the economy to see the vulnerabilities and address them by putting some risk management measures in place to address these vulnerabilities

     

    1. Why are we going to the IMF?

     

    Ans. Basically we are going to IMF to assist us getting all our creditors to agree to a debt restructuring once we sign up to a economic performance improvement plan (PIP)

     

    If Ghana brings a credible performance improvement plan IMF will get approval to assist Ghana with a loan to help with the budget

     

    We are not going to the IMF solely for a financial bail out ie IMF funds will not solve our problem

     

    The IMF will insist on financial discipline and should also insist for Govt to address the structural imbalances such as :

    – Low taxation

    – High imports of goods and commoditiesthat can be produced here

    – High unemployment

    – Low growth in key sectors

    – High Govt sector employment

    – Relatively high compensation to

    – low productivity of Govt workers

     

    Govt need to be forced not to hide its challenges.

     

    These structural imbalances can be achieved if the following are addressed:

    – Dampening inflation

    – Lower nominal interest rates

    – Encourage private investment in the real sector

    – Spur economic growth

    – Lower transactions costs

     

    All the above are needed to reduce the deficits and also for debt reduction

     

     

    1. What will happen if we do not get a workable PIP and the resulting bailout for IMF?

     

    Ans. Things could only get worse.

    Capital will begin to dry up – we are currently shut out of Eurobond markets

     

    Ghana could face a liquidity crises and will need even larger bailout financing

     

    Ghana could emerge into a recession amidst hyperinflation

     

    Government tax revenues would weaken

     

    This will find many companies failing especially the SMEs which will result in job losses will exasperate the already precarious unemployment situation in the country